Pizza ManA few weeks back, a friend of Natasha's recommended this place to her, claiming they had the best hot dogs this side of Chicago. Never ones to miss out on that most-American of delicacies, we decided try out Pizza Man at 10212 Pflumm in Lenexa on hot and sweltering August Sunday.
En route, I received a call from my friends Zack and Donovan, apparently Donavan's alternator had decided to give out, thus stranding them in the concrete jungle known as downtown Overland Park. Being the generous friend I am (and ever so humble), we swung by Firestone and picked them up, inviting them to join us on our latest culinary adventure.
Pizza Man has a terrible location. In a strip mall just north of 103rd street on Pflumm, it's also about 2 blocks from Stonewall Pizza, and close to pretty much nothing else. With Pflumm having no easy access to either 435 or 35, it's a road I rarely travel. But, secure in the knowledge that this was where Pizza Man was located, thanks to a print-off of Google maps, we had no difficulty finding the place.
Clearly Pizza Man prides itself on its Chicago roots. When you enter, the entire place is painted in Cubs blue (which is like Kryptonite to me, a Cardinals fan), and decorated with Chicago-themed prints and Cubs logos. One whole wall is dedicated to a mural of notable Chicago athletes, including Ernie Banks, Walter Payton, Bobby Hull, and of course, Michael Jordan.
We placed our order at the counter with a man, probably the owner, wearing a well-worn Cubs shirt. The menu offered several types of hot dogs, including the requisite Chicago Dog, several hot sandwiches and pizza. Prices were very reasonable, the hot dogs were around $3 each, sandwiches $5, and pizza, depending on size anywhere from $5 to $12, or so. Natasha and I both choose Chicago dogs, and we split a small pizza, mushrooms and Italian sausage, which the man behind the counter assured me was their best topping. Zack choose a combo sandwich of pork and beef sausage, and Donovan had a hamburger pizza. We all choose Cherry Coke, which in case you weren't aware, is the greatest drink available from a soda fountain.
As the food is cooked to order, we had a little while to wait before we received it. This was fine with me, as it gave me a chance to try out the Mortal Kombat II video game. Not having played this game since, oh about 1993, give or take a few years, I remembered none of the moves and proceeded to get humiliated in the first round. Luckily, Donavan, who prides himself on his video game prowess, also suffered a loss. Neither one of us remembered that game as being so difficult.
In relatively short order, our food arrived. The Chicago Dogs were spot on. I've had lots of hot dogs in my life, but these were exactly how I remember them in the Windy City, right down to the poppy seed buns, the unnaturally green relish, and the all-beef wieners. Yep, this was a Chicago Dog all right, and a good one to boot.
The pizza was also a good choice. Though I have to admit, it was different than I expected. I was thinking Uno-style, deep dish pie with the sauce on top. This was more like a thin St. Louis-style crust, but it was cooked perfectly, with just the right amount of crunch without being burnt. The sauce had a slight zip to it, and I'm pretty certain it was home-made. They used fresh mushrooms, which is extremely important to me, but the real star of the show was the Italian sausage. Normally Italian sausage is hit-or-miss with me, as most places overdo it with one or more spices, usually fennel. Not a problem with Pizza Man, they perfectly walked that tightrope, and added just enough fennel to season the meat without overpowering it. Very well done...
But as Lavarr Burton would say, don't take my word for it. Read KC Lunch Spots' review
here.
Scorecard
Food: 5
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 4
Menu: 5
Price: 5
Total: 22
Average: 4.4