Blue GrottoOut of business in a year. That's my prediction for this supposedly hip spot at 6324 Brookside Plaza. Yes, remember you heard it here first, I'm stating right now that Chef Chris Graham's latest creation, Blue Grotto, will join the ill-fated 85% of restaurants and close its doors within the first year, unless of course, they make some major changes.
We decided to try this place last Saturday. From the first impression Blue Grotto struck me as a place " to see and be seen" much more than a serious eatery. I was not wrong.
It was crowded as we made our way past a crowd of wannabe-hipsters and social butterflies to the hostess' stand. Just past the bar we put our names on the waiting list. We were told it was about a 10 minute wait so we decided to grab a drink at the bar. This was a mistake. First of all, there's absolutely nowhere to stand while waiting for your table, so we were pushed into an uncomfortable position between a pseudo-fashionable couple and the waitresses' drink station. After being repeatedly ignored by the bartender, we were finally served by the restaurant's manager. I had a Stella and Natasha had a glass of wine from their wine list, and somehow our total was $12.85. Now the drink prices were high, but what really irked me was the 15 cents change I received. You show me a bar anywhere in the world whose drinks don't end in a multiple of 25, and I'll show you a place full of assholes... did I already mention that? The fact that Blue Grotto was packed wall-to-wall with assholes? Because it was, but I digress...
Eventually, after a few minutes of inadvertently invading the personal space of others due to a lack of standing room, we were shown to our table, a four-top at the head of the stairs on the second level, where the main dining room is located. Within a few minutes we were offered ice water, in those ridiculously tall and thin glasses that are apparently trendy, by the only person in the place who seemed to give a damn about us, a Mexican busboy who barely spoke English.
We were also give menus, which we examined in depth. Pizza prices were okay, around $12-14 for most, but there's only a small selection (maybe ten), and most everything has red onions, one of the only foods I dislike. Appetizer choices are also limited, around six, with prices considerably higher than I like, around $10. There were also about five salad choices, all around $12.
Set with our waters and drinks, and having made up our minds already as to food, we waited for our waitress. And waited. And waited. And waited, until finally, she noticed us.
"Oh sorry, you guys, I didn't see you'd been seated," she told us, a dubious story at best, as we were located right at the head of the stairs. Maybe it's true, however, and I would have given her the benefit of the doubt, had she stopped there, but she didn't. She asked if this was our first visit to Blue Grotto, to which we replied in the affirmative. This set her off on a explanation of the menu, during which she talked to us like we were drooling idiots freshly released from the sanitarium. When she started explaining what constitutes a margherita pizza, Natasha and I shared a glance, both of us thinking, "Though this is our first time in this particular establishment, we have, in fact, had pizza before." I hate being treated like a moron, but I have the impression that this was a well-practiced spiel she gives everyone.
Anyway, when she finally finished her diatribe, we told her we had already decided and we wanted the artichoke dip appetizer and a four seasons pizza. She took our order, insincerely thanked us, and left us to study our surroundings.
As anyone who knows me will attest, I'm not a big fan of the modern style of architecture, but the owners of Blue Grotto apparently are. The walls were a dull gray (why not blue?), and everything was made of steel. Featuring exposed heating ducts, which I hate, this place had the worst acoustics ever, as there was nothing soft to absorb sound waves. As a result, I had the feeling I was eating on the tarmac at an airport, with Natasha and I nearly shouting across the table at each other. Even the cutlery of this place annoyed me, big, heavy utensils, including a knife that resembled nothing so much as a miniature axe.
We also had plenty of time to observe the staff. The pizza is made in a wood-fired oven in the center of the first floor, and from our vantage point we could see everything. The kitchen staff seemed diligent enough, but the food itself, especially its presentation annoyed me. One of the most popular appetizers seemed to be a gargantuan cheese, fruit and cracker plate. Served on a rectangular plate nearly two feet long, it almost didn't fit on the tables, yet somehow, was extremely popular. Also, the salads were served in the pretentious whole-leaf style. That is, diners were presented with entire, unshredded leaves of lettuce, which of course, require the use of a knife. Depending on the server, some diners were offered fresh-cracked pepper for their salads, while others were not...
Eventually our appetizer arrived. The menu promised artichoke dip with roasted red peppers and pita chips. While the dip was okay, artichokes with parmesan served cold, decent texture and flavor, the "roasted" red peppers were in fact, raw, and the pita chips almost certainly came from a bag. That really irritated me. While the bagged ones taste alright, how difficult is it to provide a personal touch by cutting up some pitas (you can buy day-old ones cheap), and dropping them in the fryer?
Of course our waitress didn't check on us, and the Mexican busboy (really my favorite person in the place) cleared our dishes. We next saw our waitress when our pizza arrived. The pizza, called "Four Seasons" featured four sections, each with a topping representing a season. Spring was artichokes, roasted red peppers were summer, mushrooms were autumn, and olives were winter. Served without the accouterments of every pizza in the country, parmesan and red pepper flakes, the pizza was also practically devoid of cheese. The crust was dry and bland, more doughy than it should be. The toppings were mostly okay (but how do you screw up olives?), except the roasted red peppers were also underseasoned.
Maybe because my last wood-fired pizza experience was so good, ( see Il Vicino), I expected more, but at any rate, Blue Grotto didn't even come close to delivering. While we were waiting on our check (did I mention the inattentive servers?), my Stella ran through me and I tried to use the facilities. I say tried, because apparently this restaurant that seats around 70, only sees the need for a restroom that serves one at a time, which was at that time occupado. Disgusted with this annoyance, on top of everything else, I retreated to our table to wait on our bill. Eventually it did come, and I paid with a credit card. However when our waitress returned with the reciept, she didn't have a pen. Really??? You're a professional waitress and you don't have a pen??? Luckily Natasha had one in her purse, so we could get the hell out of there.
I'll tell you now, the only way I'd ever return to Blue Grotto is if someone gave me a gift certificate or offered to buy my dinner, and even then, I'd probably try to go somewhere else. Do yourself a favor, the next time you're in Brookside and want a pizza, pass by Blue Grotto, there's a Domino's right down the street. The pizza will be comparable and you won't have to deal with any of the other nonsense. Unless, of course, you're a pretentious douche yourself, and then by all means, join your kind at Blue Grotto.
Scorecard
Food: 1.2
Atmosphere: .7
Service: .5
Menu: 2.3
Price: 2.3
Total: 7
Average: 1.4







